Mon - Sat 9:00 - 17:30
Employees working in chemical, petrochemical and pharmaceutical carriers carry out activities such as sampling of process streams, catalyst handling, tank gauging, solvent transfer, filter change-outs and loading/unloading drums. In many of these jobs, air-purifying respirators (APRs) are commonly used.
In-house Job Safety Analysis (JSA) often recommends APRs, but the real question is: what is the basis for deciding whether it is solving the purpose? Is it just team judgement, or do we need scientific validation through exposure monitoring?
Occupational exposure is not only about the chemical concentration (ppm or mg/m³) but also the time a worker spends exposed. Standards define exposure limits as:
Time Weighted Average (TWA): Usually an 8-hour average over a shift.
Short-Term Exposure Limit (STEL): Average over 15 minutes.
Ceiling Limit: Must never be exceeded at any time.
So, even if a cartridge mask protects against a chemical up to a certain ppm, its effectiveness must be judged against how long the worker is exposed and whether the overall dose stays below the occupational exposure limit (OEL).
Half-face APRs (with correct cartridges): Suitable up to 10 × OEL (e.g., if the OEL is 50 ppm, respirator may be used up to 500 ppm).
Full-face APRs: Suitable up to 50 × OEL.
Powered APRs (PAPRs): Can go higher depending on configuration and filter type.
Beyond those concentrations OR in oxygen-deficient/IDLH environments → Supplied Air Respirators (air-line or SCBA) are mandatory.
Example: If the permissible exposure limit (PEL) for toluene is 200 ppm (OSHA ceiling) and a worker is exposed to 150 ppm for 2 hours, 80 ppm for 3 hours, and 20 ppm for 3 hours → the 8-hour TWA = [(150×2)+(80×3)+(20×3)] ÷ 8 = 70 ppm, which is within limits. Respirator selection must therefore consider both ppm and exposure duration.
Oxygen < 19.5%
IDLH conditions or concentrations > APF capacity
Unknown contaminants or peaks likely
Confined space entry
OSHA 29 CFR 1910.134 – Respiratory Protection
NIOSH APF Tables – Assigned Protection Factors
ISO/TS 16975 series – RPE Programme Guidance
EN 14387 / EN 136 – European respirator standards
BIS IS 9473, IS 8347 – Indian standards for respirators
✅ Bottom line: Cartridge masks are not “one size fits all.” Their protection is limited by ppm concentration, duration of exposure, cartridge type and APF value. Without scientific exposure monitoring, relying only on team judgement is risky.
👉 For more such practical HSE insights, follow us.
📩 For correct PPE selection, exposure monitoring and HSE system implementation, contact Agni Raksha Niti at info@agnirakshaniti.com.
We offer a full suite of HSEFS services designed to address your specific challenges and goals : HSE Consulting & Advisory, HSE Auditing & Assurance, HSE Training & Development, Implementation & Support, Environmental Services
Copyright 2025. Agni Raksha Niti Engineering Consultancy Services Pvt. Ltd. All Rights Reserved.